标题:themoreineptyouarethesmarteryouthinkyouare。 source:bbcbyTomStafford 欲翻译的小伙伴,可评论领稿,并把已完成的译文贴在评论处或发在自己的心理圈内。谢谢 Yreprettysmartright?Clever,andfunnytoo。Ofcourseyouare,justlikeme。Btitbeterribleifweweremistaken?Psychologistshaveshownthatwearemorelikelytobeblindtoourownfailingsthanperhapswerealise。Thiscouldexplainwhysomeincompetentpeoplearesoannoying,andalsoinjectahealthydoseofhumilityintoourownsenseofselfregard。 In1999,JustinKrugerandDavidDunning,fromCornellUniversity,NewYork,testedwhetherpeoplewholacktheskillsorabilitiesforsomethingarealsomorelikelytolackawarenessoftheirlackofability。AtthestartoftheirresearchpapertheyciteaPittsburghbankrobbercalledMcArthurWheelerasanexample,whowasarrestedin1995shortlyafterrobbingtwobanksinbroaddaylightwithoutwearingamaskoranyotherkindofdisguise。Whenpoliceshowedhimthesecuritycamerafootage,ButI。Thehaplesscriminalbelievedthatifyourubbedyourfacewithlemonjuiceyouwouldbeinvisibletosecuritycameras。 KrugerandDunningwereinterestedintestinganotherkindoflaughingmatter。Theyaskedprofessionalcomedianstorate30jokesforfunniness。Then,65undergraduateswereaskedtoratethejokestoo,andthenrankedaccordingtohowwelltheirjudgementsmatchedthoseoftheprofessionals。Theywerealsoaskedhowwelltheythoughttheyhaddonecomparedtotheaverageperson。 Asyoumightexpect,mostpeoplethoughttheirabilitytotellwhatwasfunnywasaboveaverage。Theresultswere,however,mostinterestingwhensplitaccordingtohowwellparticipantsperformed。Thoseslightlyaboveaverageintheirabilitytoratejokeswerehighlyaccurateintheirselfassessment,whilethosewhoactuallydidthebesttendedtothinktheywereonlyslightlyaboveaverage。Participantswhowereleastabletojudgewhatwasfunny(atleastaccordingtotheprofessionalcomics)werealsoleastabletoaccuratelyassesstheirownability。 Thisfindingwasnotaquirkoftryingtomeasuresubjectivesenseofhumour。Theresearchersrepeatedtheexperiment,onlythistimewithtestsoflogicalreasoningandgrammar。Thesedisciplineshavedefinedanswers,andineachcasetheyfoundthesamepattern:thosepeoplewhoperformedtheworstwerealsotheworstinestimatingtheirownaptitude。Inallthreestudies,thosewhoseperformanceputtheminthelowestquartermassivelyoverestimatedtheirownabilitiesbyratingthemselvesasaboveaverage。 Itdidn’tevenhelpthepoorperformerstobegivenabenchmark。Inalaterstudy,themostincompetentparticipantsstillfailedtorealisetheywerebottomofthepackevenwhengivenfeedbackontheperformanceofothers。 KrugerandDsinterpretationisthataccuratelyassessingskilllevelreliesonsomeofthesamecoreabilitiesasactuallyperformingthatskill,sotheleastcompetentsufferadoubledeficit。Notonlyaretheyincompetent,buttheylackthementaltoolstojudgetheirownincompetence。 Inakeyfinaltest,KrugerandDunningtrainedagroupofpoorperformersinlogicalreasoningtasks。Thisimprovedparticipants’selfassessments,suggestingthatabilitylevelsreallydidinfluenceselfawareness。 Oeffectholdsinreallifesituations,notjustinabstractlaboratorytests。Forexample,hunterswhoknowtheleastaboutfirearmsalsohavethemostinaccurateviewoftheirfirearmknowledge,anddoctorswiththeworstpatientinterviewingskillsaretheleastlikelytorecognisetheirinadequacies。 WhathasbecomeknownastheDunningKrugereffectisanexampleofwhatpsychologistscallmetacognitionthinkingaboutthinking。It’salsosomethingthatshouldgiveusallpauseforthought。Theeffectmightjustexplaintheapparentlybafflingselfbeliefofsomeofyourfriendsandcolleagues。Butbeforeyoustartgettingtoosmug,justrememberonething。Asunlikelyasyoumightthinkitis,youtoocouldbewalkingaroundblissfullyignorantofyourignorance。